Compulsory apps on school tablet devices: Friend or foe?
Sixth year Medical Student from the University of Adelaide, supervised by Prof Jon Jureidini
After a year of COVID, children have been engaging with digital tablets, apps and other digitalized resources more than ever, often as required by their schools. Before COVID, 93% of UK children aged 8-11 were found to go online in any given week in a study by their communication regulator, Ofcom. Meanwhile, a US study found 95% of a sample of popular ‘under 5 apps’ had advertisements and in an Australian study, 82% of mental health apps accessed data from the users of that app. It might be expected that online learning will remain high after the pandemic passes, so it is timely we assess the use of such tools, particularly regarding child safety, and the benefits and cost of apps.
Our study investigated the use and potential harms of children’s apps. We analysed 47 apps that were deemed ‘compulsory’ for download by one primary school in an Australian capital city. Only 18 apps (38%) fitted into a typical primary school subject category, (e.g., Mathletics Student), and the others mostly had operational utility, (e.g., word processing, Microsoft Word) or were expected to enhance digital-technology skills (e.g., Adobe Photoshop). While there is evidence to suggest educational apps can be beneficial for children’s learning, their effective use might require additional teaching training. Often missing from the compulsory list, as in our study, are educational apps such as Minecraft that encourage creative engagement and problem-solving.
Furthermore, there are studies that suggest that the use of tablets can compromise or encourage development of hand and fine motor skills, and this depends very much on the app under review. These mixed messages make it complicated for parents and educators to make decisions about the appropriate kinds of apps for their children. Read more.
Of greater concern to parents and educators are the potential risks associated with data sharing, advertising, and content that apps can generate.
There is much work to be done to support children to monitor what they are exposed to when they use digital apps. A strong parent and educator agenda goes beyond supervising children’s app use to more engagement with children in their app use. This approach is particularly important when schools provide lists of approved school apps. Children are being exposed to advertising with a UK study finding that only 23% of children ages 8-11 years-old could identify sponsored links that appeared on Google as advertising.
Harms to self-esteem
Some of the apps downloaded, including Adobe Photoshop and Pic Collage Kids, involved editing photos and posting them online for others to view. These apps that encourage the posting of images can raise questions about a child’s (or adult’s) self-image and confidence. Links between social media use and low self-esteem (as well as anxiety, depression and poor sleep) require further investigation. Some apps, including the popular Mathletics, provide feedback online, which may affect students’ learning as the feedback is not moderated through an educator or parent who could gauge the impact on that particular child. Should schools be exacerbating already pervasive app use by mandating the download of particular apps?
While the majority of 47 apps listed for download on iPads of Years 3-5 students at one Australian primary school had potential educational or operational utility use, significant concerns were identified about: the collection of user data that is commonly shared with third parties and used for targeted advertising; exposure to advertising; and unintended impact on well-being and learning. On the other hand, some apps could be educationally or socially beneficial and there are resources that help identify these.
- Meyer M et al. 2019 ‘Advertising in Young Children’s Apps: A Content Analysis’ J Dec Behav Pediatr Jan; 40 (1):32-39
- Outhwaite LA, Gulliford A & Pitchford NJ (2017) ‘Closing the gap: Efficacy of a tablet intervention to support the development of early mathematical skills in UK primary school children’ Computers and Education 108 May 2017 43-58
- Flewitt R, Messer D & Kucirkova N (2014) ‘New directions for early literacy in a digital age: The iPad’ J Early Childhood Literacy 15 (3)
- Chaudron S (2015) ‘Young Children (0-8) and digital technology: A qualitative exploratory study across seven countries’ Publications Office of the European Union JRC93239
- Rodgers RF, et al. (2020) ‘A Biopsychosocial Model of Social Media Use and Body Image Concerns, Disordered Eating, and Muscle-Building Behaviors among Adolescent Girls and Boys’ J Youth Adolesc 49(2):399-409
- Cleland Woods H & Scott H (2016) ‘#Sleepyteens: Social media use in adolescence is associated with poor sleep quality, anxiety, depression and low self-esteem’ J Adolesc 51:41-9
Pisaniello, M. & Jureidini, J. (2021). 'Compulsory apps on school tablet devices- Friend or Foe?'. CEMH Blog. 29 July 2021. Available at: https://www.adelaide.edu.au/robinson-research-institute/critical-and-et… [date accessed].